How a content library becomes a content engine: Pigment's story

If you run content at a B2B SaaS or fintech company, you probably have years of blog posts, event recaps, gated reports, and webinar recordings gathering dust on your website. They cover some topics over and over, while other topics aren’t addressed at all, including ones your buyers actively search for and care about. Now, AI engines are reading your content, too, deciding whether and how to mention your brand in responses that shape buyers’ vendor consideration sets.
A content audit is how you get your library under control and turn it into a content engine for your brand—one where each piece reinforces what you want to be known for and drives discoverability, whether buyers are searching on Google or asking an AI assistant.
But most content audits are just an inventory of assets. Valuable content audits go further. They decide what each existing asset should become, so what you've already published keeps growing in value. They also reveal what's missing, so every piece you commission next is a strategic decision.
The audit we ran for Pigment—the AI-native business planning platform—did both, and it became the foundation for the content program we’ve been building with them ever since.
Below is the process we followed in six steps: how to set up the inventory, which questions to ask, what moves to make on each piece, how to turn your decisions into a content structure that builds search authority, how to adapt that structure for AI search, and how to keep the work up to date. We'll point back to our work with Pigment along the way.
Step 1: Start with your goals, then build the inventory
Before you look at a single page, be clear on your company’s business and marketing objectives. Every call you make later should be in support of those goals.
For most B2B tech companies, a top priority is discoverability, meaning buyers can find you when they look for help with the problems you solve. That’s why search engine optimization (SEO) and answer engine optimization (AEO) are a part of every step outlined below.
From there, build the inventory in a spreadsheet:
- Create one row for every piece you’ve published, whether it's an article, report, guide, template, or webinar.
- For each, capture the basics like date, author, URL, gating, CTA, and current tag.
- Add your own labels for important details like content type, topic, purpose, and funnel stage.
- Add columns for your call on each piece (keep, refresh, merge, repurpose, or archive), along with your reasoning and prioritization.
The reasoning column matters most. It lets a colleague who disagrees see how you got there, and it keeps the conversation rooted in evidence rather than opinion.
Next, bring in your analytics:
- For each URL, pull clicks, impressions, click-through rate, average position, and top queries from Search Console, plus engagement rate, engagement time, and key events from GA4.
- Use the same date ranges for every piece. Comparing quarter by quarter shows which pieces are rising, holding steady, or fading, which is information you can’t get from an opinion alone.
- If you don’t have direct access to the analytics, write up exactly which reports you need, and hand that request to whoever does.
Finally, add keyword research. Group the searches your buyers commonly run into topic clusters, noting the search volume, ranking difficulty, and intent for each, and map your existing pages against them. A competitor gap analysis rounds things out by showing the keywords and topics your competitors rank for and you don’t. Together, they show where your library is already competing in search and where it’s still absent.
What we did for Pigment: We framed our audit around Pigment's five specific marketing objectives for the year, which included accelerating demand generation through organic search. Our completed inventory covered roughly 220 URLs, each with a keep, refresh, merge, repurpose, or archive label that Pigment's team could filter and sort. We also mapped Pigment’s existing pages against keyword clusters for core topics and ran a competitor gap analysis against other business planning platforms in their space.
Step 2: Ask six questions of your library
With the inventory built, look across it rather than piece by piece. We typically use six lenses:
- Range: Where are the critical gaps or overlaps in coverage?
- Reach: How is your gating strategy affecting lead generation?
- Relevance: Was an asset built to last or tied to a moment that has passed?
- Navigation: Can a visitor find and reach your key pieces easily?
- Design: Is your visual strategy set up to drive the outcomes you want?
- Brand: Is your positioning and identity, including voice, consistent from piece to piece?
Work through these across your whole content library to reveal patterns, opportunities, and gaps. Your website analytics can also make each answer more precise. For example:
- Search Console queries show which of your pages compete for the same searches and which valuable searches have no page at all.
- Conversion data from Google Analytics, like form submissions as a share of page visits, shows whether your gating is helping or hurting.
- Quarter-over-quarter traffic and engagement show whether an older piece is still earning its place.
Where data is missing or unreliable, say so in the inventory so no one mistakes a guess for a finding.
What we did for Pigment: Pigment’s library had real range and depth, which gave us a lot to work with. Our audit uncovered several critical opportunities. Pigment had covered certain financial planning and analysis (FP&A) topics many times over. But financial reporting—a cluster of terms drawing roughly 4,400 monthly searches—had only two articles devoted to it, and topics around financial statements like the P&L and balance sheet had none. That meant Pigment could consolidate overlapping posts into strong single pages while filling gaps with content buyers were already looking for.
We found similar openings elsewhere. Ungating trust-building assets like impact studies would put Pigment’s strongest proof points in front of more buyers, while practical tools like frameworks and checklists would offer a better trade for an email address. And posts tied to past events like Pigment’s FP&A Week held evergreen insights that could be repackaged and updated in refreshed content. Where we couldn’t confirm a finding, we added follow-up notes and questions to run through with the Pigment team.
Step 3: Decide what each piece becomes
This is where an audit starts to pay back. For every existing piece, choose one of five moves:
- Refresh pieces where the ideas are evergreen but tied to a one-time event.
- Recycle outdated pieces into something new, so the earlier effort isn't wasted.
- Archive pieces that can't be refreshed or repurposed.
- Preserve on-demand content, such as video, by keeping it timeless.
- Repurpose your high performers across different formats and channels.
Check the data before you commit to a move. A dated piece that still brings steady traffic or earns links usually deserves a refresh or careful redirect rather than an archive. A piece with many impressions but few clicks may need a stronger title or a clearer answer toward the top.
While you're at it, set a rule for gating. Ungate the assets that build confidence in your product, such as case studies, product guides, and impact studies. Gate the ones that offer buyers real value, such as original research or a tool they can use. Then test the rule: compare form submissions as a share of page visits for your gated assets, and try different ways of capturing contact details, such as a landing-page form versus a form partway through the piece, on a few of them.
Finally, check the voice. A library that sounds like five different companies doesn't build a unified brand, so note the range of tone you find, and write a style guide to bring it together.
What we did for Pigment: These moves turned a long list of older posts into a set of clear decisions. Many of those decisions were to consolidate or refresh rather than to start over, for three reasons:
- Merging overlapping posts into one stronger page stops a site from competing with itself in search and concentrates authority in a single URL.
- Refreshing evergreen pieces lets content that has already earned rankings and links keep working instead of quietly fading.
- Because the raw material already existed, Pigment could strengthen a large share of its library with far less effort than writing new pieces from scratch.
We also recommended ungating trust-builders like Pigment’s Total Economic Impact (TEI) study and third-party analyst reports. In their place, we suggested Pigment turn practical checklists buried in blog posts into gated, downloadable tools. We also recommended putting together a simple voice and style guide to keep the brand personality consistent.
Step 4: Turn the decisions into a structure
Identifying which assets to keep, refresh, merge, repurpose, and archive is useful. A structure for them is better.
We recommend building around a hub-and-spoke model, where broad pillar pages cover each core topic in depth and link to focused spoke pages, and each page owns its own set of keywords. The real value is in the links between them. When a pillar and spokes link to one another, they signal to search engines that your site covers a topic thoroughly, and that topical authority helps every page in the cluster rank higher. Giving each page its own keywords also keeps your pages from competing with one another for the same searches (often referred to as “keyword cannibalization”).
The structure also tells you what content you really need. Once keyword clusters are mapped to pillars, the missing spokes become visible as the topics buyers search for that no page on your site currently answers, and that can help shape new content ideas. Start with the spokes you can build by merging and refreshing existing posts, since the raw material is already there, and move on to net-new pieces after that. These can be prioritized by search volume, difficulty, intent, and how closely each topic connects to what you sell. Your competitor gap analysis, conversations with sales reps and customers, and the questions buyers ask AI tools are all useful inputs, too.
What we did for Pigment: The audit led to a content plan built around pillar pages for Pigment's three focus areas: FP&A, sales performance management (SPM), and AI for business planning. We used the keyword research from Step 1 to decide which spokes each pillar needed and in what order.
The first spokes came from merging and refreshing posts the inventory had already flagged, like Pigment’s guides to financial forecasting, sales capacity planning, and extended planning and analysis (xP&A). One of them filled the gap we surfaced during Step 2, as we expanded an existing financial reporting guide into a dedicated spoke page. Net-new content followed once those pieces were in place and performing well.
Step 5: Reuse the inventory when the rules change
The same structure that builds authority in Google also gives you a head start in AI search. Today, the question isn’t only how you rank on search engine results pages, but whether AI tools find and cite your content and mention your brand in their generated responses. Tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, and Google’s AI Overviews draw on pages they can easily find, understand, and trust, then summarize them for buyers. AEO is the work of making your content easy for those tools to retrieve, interpret correctly, and cite.
A library that has already been consolidated, sensibly tagged, and organized into a clear structure is a better starting point, because each topic has one clear page for AI tools to draw from instead of several competing ones. For older pieces especially, we recommend using question-style headings with short answer summaries directly underneath, so readers and AI tools alike can find the answer they need quickly. Including clear definitions, consistent terminology from page to page, and FAQs that answer likely follow-up questions helps, too.
What we did for Pigment: When we took on AI search with Pigment through a later AEO audit, we started from our original content inventory instead of from scratch. Many of the calls we had made, like pruning event-tied posts and content from former team members, carried straight over. We then built a second catalog that looked at each page the way an AI tool would. For every page, we recommended where it should live on Pigment’s site—for example, moving “what is” explainers into a dedicated guides section—flagged pages at risk of competing with one another, mapped internal links, and noted which pages needed FAQs, glossary links, or clearer, more readable copy.
Step 6: Keep it alive
An audit that sits in a folder goes stale. Plan to revisit the findings and recommendations every planning cycle. Mark what's done, what's left to do, and what’s changed, and pull the same performance metrics over the same date ranges so you can see whether your decisions worked. A living inventory also protects your brand as new content arrives, because every new piece has a place and a purpose before it's written.
What we did for Pigment: When we planned Pigment’s content for the year, the audit was our starting point. It told us what remained to be done, and it set a baseline for measuring what worked. Because every page had a recorded decision behind it, we could trace which of our calls had moved Pigment’s organic traffic.
What it all added up to
Driving performance through strategies like SEO takes time, and it’s worth setting that expectation early on. For Pigment, gains for keywords we’d targeted spiked roughly four to six months after the core pillar and spoke pages went live.
By about ten months after the audit, six of the top 20 sources of organic traffic to Pigment’s website were pages we had written or refreshed, while only three other blog posts made that list. The financial reporting guide, built to fill a gap we surfaced, had become the site’s second-largest source of organic traffic after the homepage.
A good audit doesn't just report on what exists. It makes decisions piece by piece, gives the team a shared vocabulary, says plainly what it couldn't measure, and points to what to build next. That is how a library of content turns into an engine that builds your brand and keeps it visible wherever your buyers are looking. If your library looks like the one we described at the start, the six questions in Step 2 are a good place to begin.

